Best Compact for Street Photography?

Dennis (dmcguire) asks in our Flickr group discussion section, what is the "best compact for street photography?" 

Documentary photography has long been a strength of compact cameras, both film and digital. While portability is less of a factor for most landscape photography, excepting perhaps the mountain climber or hiker who needs to travel light, it is a great advantage for documentary work. Compared with larger cameras, compacts are easier to take everywhere and keep ready for any moment that should arise. Compact cameras are also more discreet than larger cameras. This can be an asset, not necessarily because of stealth, but because a less distracting camera may make it easier to document a moment without affecting its content.

Whether "street" or otherwise, the list of documentary photographers who have put compacts to outstanding use is beyond the scope of this blog post. Here are a few to consider:

  • Magnum photographer Alex Majoli used Olympus digital compacts for award-winning photojournalism (link).
  • New York street photographer Markus Hartel makes use of a variety of compacts including the GRD II and Sigma DP1 (link).
  • Magnum photographer Peter van Agtmael also uses digital compacts including the GRD (in addition to the Leica Digilux 2 and others).  See his Lightstalkers gallery with intact EXIF data (link).
Share your thoughts about compact cameras for documentary photography here in the comments or the Flickr discussion thread started by Dennis (link).

Posted by Amin

Comments (4)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Jim in Denver's avatar

Jim in Denver · 827 weeks ago

I think the 'best' compact for street photography is going to be a somewhat personal question - specifically, long lens or short? If you are a get in close person, a wider than normal zoom range (I.E., 24mm equivalent or more) will give that street look that is gritty and just a bit in the personal space of the subject.
On the other hand, if you are interested in stealing a moment of an unaware subject, a but longer than normal zoom range would be a big help.
Regardless of focal length considerations, a camera for street photography needs to have an extremely responsive and fast focus and shutter.
I use a GRD2 and a LX3. The GRD2 is the better "street photography" camera. Set on "snap" mode (prefocused to approx. 3 m), there is negligible shutter lag. But the 3:4 aspect ratio is limiting, and it can't handle poor light, so I use it less than half the time. The LX3 is also a great street photography camera, but I often encounter significant shutter lag (despite using manual focus), which has resulted in too many missed shots. I guess I'm still waiting for the perfect street photography compact.
This is Dennis McGuire. It's great to see the Flickr discussion continued here, because it was the "Ten Recommended Compacts" article that got me seriously thinking about a replacement. Thanks to all the responses to my query on the flickr group, the GRD seems like the answer to my shooting needs, but looking back at the recommended ten, the GX 100 and 200 also seem pretty appealing. My favorite lenses in the film world are the 28mm, 35mm and 50mm, in that order. So the I'm guessing the stepped-zoom would give me the option to shoot at those relative focal lengths and it would be nice to have the 24mm option, to experiment with, as well. I like being physically close to what I'm shooting, so 72mm, at the other end of the zoom spectrum, would be more than enough. Compared to the GRD, I wonder if there are any timing issues or other drawbacks with the GX, that would make it less than ideal for my intended purpose. By the way thanks for the links provided...some great pictures, the Alex Majoli stuff, especially. Awesome to think of pictures being made under those conditions, with a small digital camera.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
Hi Dennis, When using the snap focus and manual metering the GX200 becomes a very fast and responsive camera. The main draw back could be the poorer high ISO performance in my opinion. It is good at ISO 100 and usable at ISO 200.

Post a new comment

Comments by

 
Copyright 2007 | Andreas08v2 by GeckoandFly and TemplatesForYou | Design by Andreas Viklund
TFY Burajiru