Ten Recommended Compacts: Number 10

Inspired by The Online Photographer, who have begun a countdown of their T.O.P. Ten Recommended Cameras, I thought I'd offer a list of ten recommended compact cameras.

My search for the perfect compact has taken me back and forth between digital and film. In terms of size, I've used everything that could be considered compact, from the smallest of subcompacts to the most compact of DSLRs.

For the next 10 days beginning today, I'll be listing one recommended compact daily. Other than as noted, I've extensively used every camera on this list. Remember that this list is a personal one in every respect, and I haven't quite tried every compact there is to try, so don't take it to heart if your favorite compact doesn't "make it"!

#10 on my list is the Canonet QL17 GIII, shown here in the uncommon black finish next to a modern counterpart, the Canon G7:




Photo by Ken Ko, used with permission

The QL17 GIII, introduced in 1972, is a compact 35mm film rangefinder camera with a fixed 40mm f/1.7 lens. According to Steven Gandy of CameraQuest, over 1.2 million of these were sold between 1972 and 1982.

If you are looking for your first rangefinder camera experience, I can strongly recommend these inexpensive, sturdy little cameras. Notice that I didn't say light. On the contrary, these Canonets have suprising heft. They are built to last, usually requiring little more than a fresh set of batteries and light seals to function properly after decades of use.

The 40mm lens on the QL17 GIII is very sharp, even wide open. Bokeh can be harsh with the lens wide open, something that holds true for most fast lenses, but tames nicely after stopping down even slightly.

The QL17 GIII has a nice clear, bright viewfinder and reasonably crisp rangefinder patch. Those who have grown up with the niceties of digital automation will find comfort in the shutter priority auto exposure capability of the the QL17 GIII. It does not have an aperture priority mode.

The one negative to this camera is that it made to use the PX625 mercury battery, no longer available in the US. I used mine with the PX625A alkaline battery, and although this can throw off the exposure a bit, I found it worked very well overall. Alternately one can buy a camera which has been properly adjusted for the slightly different batteries.

I recommend hink2u on Ebay as a reseller of restored Canonets for a reasonable price.

More information on the Canonet QL17 GIII:
Stephen Gandy's CameraQuest
Camerapedia.org

Posted by Amin

Comments (15)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
What kind of adaptor / lens is that on the G7? Is there something like it for the G10?
1 reply · active 834 weeks ago
That's a Canon LA-DC58K conversion lens adapter. Terrible name, worse adapter if you go by the Amazon reviews. Supposedly works with the G10, but definitely check the user reviews.
What a great idea Amin. A very interesting camera by the way.
1 reply · active 834 weeks ago
Thanks Wouter!
Andrew Horodysky's avatar

Andrew Horodysky · 834 weeks ago

I second Wouter's comment. Great idea for a countdown, Amin! I'm looking forward to the next 9 days...
I can't wait to see all 10 : ) I really wish the 35mm compact was taken more seriously in this digital age.
This was the first camera with which I practiced taking photographs in my teens. Had some quirks, if I remember right, but it did cope even with low-light photography. But it was mostly used for taking family snapshots.
improbable's avatar

improbable · 834 weeks ago

Aren't they a cute pair, a whole generation of human-years apart, both dressed up alike.

Every time I see a new little camera with a flash in that position I think how quickly I'd trade it for a real full-size rangefinder-esque viewfinder. I'd be happy to let them drill a hole through the LCD there, too, like a virtual lens hood. And it doesn't have to zoom, maybe it could crop until 50mm-ish, after which you can make another plan. Mmm.
Yes, definitely a great idea for series of articles! I look forward to reading the rest.
Hi Amin, looking forward to the rest of the countdown - all interesting stuff :)
Thanks all! This will be fun to write.
Don't know how you can start a list like this , and start with a film camera , w/o mentioning the Olympus XA first , a true film compact classic.
1 reply · active 834 weeks ago
Don't forget, there are 7 more to come :-p. Not to say that the XA will or won't be one of them! Two other things: 1) I haven't owned and used all the classics, so I can't comment on some of them (but I do have an XA); 2) This list is about cameras I recommend picking up now, so certain true classics may not be recommendable right now for different reasons (expensive, likely not to work anymore, etc) - not that the XA is or isn't in that category IMO :-).
What do you think about the Yashica Electro 35 GX? This is a real gem of a 70s rangefinder! Not only is it comparatively compact and lightweight (much lighter than the Yashica Electro GSN, for instance) but in contrast to the Canonet and Olympus RC/RD and Minolta 7SII it has *aperture priority*. But most importantly, the lens is absolutely astounding, great bookeh, yet super sharp. And it also runs on modern batteries. Check cameraquest or photoethnography for further info.
The Canon GIII is indeed a great camera. I have one that I bought from Gandy some years ago now - and if I were reduced to only one film camera in my bag - I think it just might be the GIII. Now if I could just figure out a way to extract that 40mm f/1.7 lens from a non-working camera - and hack it to fit my DSLR...

Post a new comment

Comments by

 
Copyright 2007 | Andreas08v2 by GeckoandFly and TemplatesForYou | Design by Andreas Viklund
TFY Burajiru